With one exception, chalk holds in first round of high school football playoffs

With one exception, chalk holds in first round of high school football playoffs
Quarterback Luke Kincaid helped lead Benedictine to a 34-0 victory over Collegiate in the VISAA Division I semifinals. The Cadets can win their fourth consecutive state championship by beating Trinity Episcopal on Saturday (Photo by Ashley Zelenak).

A complaint registered by some high school football fans since the Virginia High School League created a new classification system, and greatly expanded the playoffs, in 2013 has been too many lopsided early-round games, especially in the first round.

Friday night gave them more reason to continue clamoring for changes as all but one top-four seed in our area’s five most-populated brackets moved on to this week’s region semifinals.

The lone exception? Gutsy New Kent, which avenged its last regular-season loss by winning a 17-9 slugfest at Tabb in a Region 3A quarterfinal pitting and fourth and fifth seeds. It is the Trojans’ first playoff win in 24 years.

New Kent now heads to top seed Petersburg, while No. 2 Hopewell gets ready to host No. 3 Booker T. Washington.

Only seven area teams saw their seasons end as Cosby fell to Manchester 6-0 in Region 6A, Douglas Freeman fell victim to a late score by Patrick Henry-Roanoke in a 16-14 loss, and Colonial Heights fell to Booker T. Washington 46-28.

Thomas Jefferson’s late-season slide could not be stopped as Armstrong shut out the Vikings 21-0 to move to a Region 2A semifinal, while Mechanicsville and Hanover saw their runs in Region 4B cut short by Courtland and Louisa, respectively. And in Region 3B, Goochland fell just short in a 17-14 loss at Warren County.

In the private-school state semifinals, Benedictine shut out Collegiate, and Trinity Episcopal came from behind to oust St. Anne’s-Belfield 21-15 to set up a Cadets/Titans state championship game for the fourth time in five years.

Click below to see updated playoff brackets at Football Championship Central.

FOOTBALL CHAMPIONSHIP CENTRAL
A regular season for the ages is complete! Now, it's time for the race to State Championship Friday/Saturday. With the VHSL moving from thre…

Region quarterfinal standouts

Armstrong’s ground game: The three-headed monster that is Kemari Cherry, Shadarus Pickett and Brennan Ball ran for 155, 127 and 102 yards, respectively, with Cherry scoring a rushing touchdown and on defense with a a pick six in the Wildcats’ 21-0 shutout of Thomas Jefferson.

Joel Nicholson, Hanover: In the best game of the quarterfinals, the Hawks’ senior almost willed his team to an upset of top-seeded Louisa in Region 4B, accounting for all five Hanover touchdowns in a 42-35 Lions win. Nicholson threw scoring strikes to J.K. Daniel, Kayden Hughes and Lane Zyglocke and had touchdown runs of 40 and 10 yards.

Midlothian’s defense: There was no doubt the Trojans would finally earn a region quarterfinal win thanks to a defensive performance highlighted by allowing 1 rushing yard total by William Fleming in a dominant 47-0. All told, the Colonels were held to 87 yards of offense.

Kemonie Peebles, Petersburg: The stock of this junior quarterback continues to rise as he threw for a pair of touchdowns in the first half and eclipsed the 300-yard mark in the Crimson Wave’s 33-0 rout of I.C. Norcom.

Unsung heroes

Louisa’s offensive line: In a back-and-forth shootout with Hanover, the Lions were down 28-14 in the second quarter. It would be the ground game that helped the Lions outscore the Hawks 28-7 the rest of the way, capped by a nine-play, 61-yard drive in the fourth quarter for the winning score. Of Louisa’s 467 yards, 268 came on the ground, helping settle down a frantic game pace and leaving Hanover little time to try and score to force overtime.

Adam Mace and Jawon Thomas, King William: Late in the fourth quarter of a Region 2A quarterfinal, Southampton had a chance to take the lead after scoring a touchdown to cut the Cavaliers’ lead to 29-28. Enter Mace and Thomas, who stopped the 2-point attempt, and in the end, sealed King William’s ticket to the region semifinals.

Playoffs game of the week

Region 4B semifinals, No. 3 Huguenot (10-1) at No. 2 Varina (9-1-1), Friday, 7 p.m.: Among fans, no potential matchup has been talked about more since the start of practice in July than a sequel to last year’s Region 4B championship between the Falcons and the Blue Devils. All tickets for the contest at James Dawkins Stadium quickly sold out. Last year, Varina jumped out to a 21-0 lead at halftime. Huguenot’s defense shut out the Blue Devils in the second half, but its comeback effort at home fell short 21-12. Whether it’s Kaleb Wyche, Zion Boisseau, or a combination of both, Varina’s quarterbacks will have to match the work of Huguenot’s Charles Scott Jr., who has committed to play at Alabama. After taking a 14-0 lead against Spotsylvania on Friday, the Falcons’ offense struggled while finishing with a 21-7 win.

Region 6A

No. 4 L.C. Bird (6-5) at No. 1 Thomas Dale (10-0), Friday, 7 p.m.: A rare Battle of Chester rematch will take place at Ed Karpus Field on Friday. The rivalry has been dominated lately by the Knights, who last lost to the Skyhawks in 2018. Thomas Dale’s win in Week 2 evened the all-time series at 27-27-1. But give L.C. Bird credit for a start-to-finish 45-0 pasting of Landstown in Friday’s quarterfinals. But Thomas Dale is rested and ready to build on an undefeated regular season. Should they keep winning, the Knights will play at home in the next three rounds and are three wins from reaching the state-championship game.

No. 3 Manchester (9-2) at No. 2 Oscar Smith (7-2-1), Friday, 7 p.m.: Oscar Smith, the two-time defending Class 6 state champions, is on a roll, winners of six straight games by a combined score of 313-21 after a rocky 1-2-1 start. Manchester’s once-mighty offense has tailed off lately, with just one touchdown from that unit in each of its past two wins. In September it looked like this might be the year a team from the 804 finally could vanquish Oscar Smith. That task appears to be a whole lot more difficult.

Region 5C

No. 4 Hermitage (8-3) at No. 1 Highland Springs (9-2), Friday, 7 p.m.:  Another rivalry rematch, this time in eastern Henrico County. This, too, is a rematch of a 2025 region-title game, won by Highland Springs at Hermitage 21-13 on Black Friday. The Panthers led for much of a contest between these teams in October before the Springers came back to take a 25-17 victory. Since then, Hermitage has played its best football of 2026, allowing less than 9 points per game and scoring an average of almost 37 points in wins over playoff teams Douglas Freeman and Thomas Jefferson and in two victories over Glen Allen. For Hermitage to take the next step and again become an elite area program, this is the mountain the Panthers must conquer.

No. 3 Patrick Henry-Roanoke (10-1) at No. 2 Midlothian (10-1), Friday, 7 p.m.: The Trojans steamrolled William Fleming 47-0 in Round 1. Now they face the Patriots, who came from behind to win a 16-14 slugfest over Douglas Freeman, the team the Trojans beat in Week 2 to begin their 10-game winning streak. Gibson Gross threw five touchdown passes in Friday’s rout of Fleming. This will be Midlothian’s toughest test since scoring back-to-back wins over Huguenot and Manchester in the regular season. One thing to clean up? The Trojans committed 15 penalties last week for 164 yards. The Patriots and Trojans will move up to Region 6A in 2027. 

Region 4B

No. 4 Courtland (9-2) at No. 1 Louisa (11-0), Friday, 7:30 p.m.: Stop us if you’ve read this before. Yet another rematch from the regular season, a 17-14 last-second win for Louisa at Courtland in Week 2. Now the Cougars seek revenge at “The Jungle” in Mineral, and, after a 35-0 win over Mechanicsville in their first home playoff game since 2015, they have to like their chances. However, as the Lions proved against Hanover, the Cougars need to keep this game low scoring, similar to their win in September. A track meet favors Louisa.

Region 3A

No. 5 New Kent (8-3) at No. 1 Petersburg (10-1), Friday, 7 p.m.: Lots of history surrounds this semifinal. This is Petersburg’s first 10-win season this century. New Kent’s victory at Tabb was its first playoff triumph since 2002, when it finished as state runner-up. Will this be a tough test for coach Scott Girolmo’s defense? Absolutely. But if New Kent can play the game at its pace, prevent big plays from Kemonie Peebles and the Crimson Wave offense and grab a turnover or two, this one could get interesting.

No. 3 Booker T. Washington (9-2) at No. 2 Hopewell (8-3), Friday, 7 p.m.: The Mighty Bookers’ renaissance has been impressive. They were 1-9 in 2024, 0-10 last year. Winners of six straight, including a 46-28 win over Colonial Heights on Friday, Booker T. Washington comes in on a roll. But Hopewell is streaking, too. Lake Taylor was outmanned and outplayed from the opening kickoff last week in a 63-12 Blue Devils triumph. The maturation of freshman quarterback Ar’King Holloway is a joy to watch. 

Region 2A

No. 4 Armstrong (9-2) at No. 1 Central-Lunenburg (11-0), Friday, 7 p.m.: All season, the wild card in this region has been the top-seeded Chargers. Their strength of schedule is such that any loss likely would have cost them the top playoffs seed. But their strength on defense is what will worry coach Jeremy Pruitt and the Wildcats. The Chargers have allowed 69 total points in their 11 victories. Thus, Armstrong must get a repeat performance from its ground game that dominated in a first-round win over Thomas Jefferson in order to challenge Lunenburg.

No. 3 King William (9-2) at No. 2 Poquoson (9-1), Friday, 7 p.m.: That rollercoaster ride we discussed last week for the Cavaliers? Well, add another stomach-churning turn as King William survived an upset threat from Southampton 29-28 to earn a trip to face the four-time defending region champions. The Islanders have won seven straight since falling to Tabb in September, including a 56-6 romp over Nottoway in the region quarterfinals. You know Poquoson has a bull’s-eye on the Cavaliers’ K’Sean Hill. But it’s King William’s defense that will need big stops. Remember, this Islanders team never has experienced a loss in the region playoffs. And, having lost in the state semifinals each of the past four years, they’re desperate to reach the Class 2 state-title game.

Region 1A

The top two seeds had byes due to forfeits and have had two weeks to prepare for Friday.

No. 4 Middlesex (6-4) at No. 1 Essex (8-2), 7 p.m.; No. 3 Northumberland (7-3) at No. 2 Rappahannock (8-2), 7

Beyond the headlines

–Championship Tuesday: Richmond Public Schools Flag Football will crown its third league champion Tuesday at 7:30 p.m. when the top seed, John Marshall, faces host Huguenot. Last year, Open High bested the Justices to win the title. The first season actually took place in the spring of last year, when John Marshall won the inaugural championship.

–Cadets vs. Titans: The Virginia Independent Schools Athletic Association Division I championship game has a very familiar ring to it. 

For the fourth time in five years, Benedictine and Trinity Episcopal will vie for the title. The top-seeded Titans will host the Cadets on Saturday afternoon.

In early September, Trinity Episcopal defeated Benedictine 7-0 during a time when the Cadets seemed to be losing players to injury left and right. After hitting their bye week at 2-3, the Cadets began to get healthier and found their stride, winners of six consecutive entering the title game. 

Trinity is seeking its first state championship since winning back-to-back titles in 2021 and 2022. The past three have belonged to Benedictine, including wins over the Titans in 2023 and 2025. It’s a highly expected, and highly anticipated, new chapter in this classic rivalry.

–Seeking the elite: A big thank you to those who have sent in nominations for the elite standouts in the RVA for the 2026 season. We welcome yours, as well! Send nominations, with statistics, to robwitham1@gmail.com anytime through Dec. 15.

Our final play

In an update to our story last week about the three-way tie coin toss at midnight outside an Oklahoma catfish restaurant, the two teams who advanced thanks to their coin landing on tails were in action Friday.

Central fell in the opener to Woodland 30-20, while Liberty was defeated by Ketchum 45-6. Thus, no Cinderella story emerged from the late-night gathering. But what a refreshing story in a year where we seem to find negative stories on the scholastic scene weekly.

This week, we want to salute a few programs whose seasons have concluded but can prepare for 2027 with optimistic outlooks.

It’s a shame that, years from now, the 2026 edition of the Cosby Titans will show a final record of 5-6. Their defense was extraordinary. They defeated L.C. Bird 7-6. Their losses to Manchester were by 18-8 and 6-0 scores. They even held the prolific Midlothian offense to 28 points, 16 below its season average.

If the Titans’ offense can catch up, Cosby could return to the glory years of its infancy as a high school twenty years ago.

Speaking of which, Cosby and Midlothian will see underclassmen leave the program with the redistricting approved for the new West Ridge High S20 school, slated to open next August. There’s no word yet on whether the new school will field a varsity football team in Year 1. For comparison, Hanover had varsity football in its first season in 2003, while Glen Allen only fielded a junior varsity squad in the fall of 2010.

The tide is turning in Goochland. While falling a bit short at Warren County on Friday, more consistent play can turn this perennial playoff participant, and former state champion, back to prominence. But Region 3B will grow to 14 teams next season in the VHSL school population realignment, making it tougher to get a top-eight spot.

And then there’s Hanover County. Mechanicsville completed its best season in 10 years at 8-3, while Hanover is in a similar boat to Cosby, finishing 5-6 despite an astounding season on offense. Both teams will lose significant contributors to graduation.

But while Hanover, and its archrival Atlee, will continue to play in Region 4B, annually one of the most difficult in the Commonwealth, Mechanicsville and its oldest rival, Patrick Henry, will move down to Region 3A. Region rivals will include Hopewell, New Kent and Colonial Heights, but not Petersburg, which will move up to Region 4B.

Does this mean a better opportunity for the county programs overall to increase playoff appearances and, hopefully, wins? Possibly. But all four programs have big questions to answer before the 2027 season.

Finally, a tip of the cap to the Collegiate Cougars. The only mountain they could not climb was Bobby Ross Stadium, where they lost their only two games in an 8-2 season. While Benedictine had their number, the Cougars earned wins over the likes of St. Anne’s-Belfield, a fellow VISAA Division I semifinalist; Fork Union; and, most importantly for the fan base, their first win over St. Christopher’s this decade.

Is a return to the glory days of Russell Wilson and Jake McGee in the cards? Stay tuned to find out.