Tom Allen: How we roll: Crime, character, and shopping carts

Tom Allen: How we roll: Crime, character, and shopping carts

A young man from a very law-abiding family I know found himself on the wrong side of the justice system a few years back after a heinous crime involving an equally heinous and well-known criminal device: a shopping cart.

Some of his college buddies, following a night on the town (an outing he was not even part of), returned to the dorm in possession of a grocery store cart that was not with them when they left. The contraband cart ended up parked in the young man’s room, where not long after, it was discovered by an alert campus security official. This led to the arrest for theft of the young man in question.

He was straightaway convicted, despite being an innocent man who just wouldn’t throw his friends under the cart, and sentenced to perform a prescribed number of hours of community service. He chose to serve his time in a thrift store in his hometown and later reported for his first day of work there.

A worker at the store, oblivious to the reason for the young man’s new undertaking, approached him and asked a favor, which went something like this: “Hey, we’re short of shopping carts right now. Can you run over to the Food Lion next door and grab a couple?”

Let’s just say this young man declined, rather immediately and somewhat adamantly. Evidently, he wasn’t interested in lengthening his rap sheet.

I was reminded of this unfortunate situation recently when I stumbled across something online called “the shopping cart theory.” Evidently, in some circles this has become a popular and allegedly foolproof way to evaluate the ethics of others. The thinking goes something like this: Because there is no law against returning your shopping cart once you’ve unloaded your acquisitions into your car, doing so becomes a test of your character. If you do what you know you’re supposed to do without the threat of punishment, and even when no one is looking, you’re a fine and moral individual. If you don’t, you’re likely a cretin. 

Some have taken issue with this, pointing out that there are legitimate reasons for not returning your cart, such as not wanting to walk away from young children in your car. Others only return carts when they think others are watching. So, as with many areas of moral behavior, there are gray areas.

However, I can only assume that if you actually steal a cart, this means you should probably be executed immediately. In aisle 3.

The question remains: What, exactly, for those outside the homeless population, for whom a shopping cart might be a lifesaver, might motivate you to steal one?

I hear some folks use carts to create funky chairs. While funky might be a hip thing to have around, I don’t think there are enough cushions and, of course, throw pillows, in the world to make a cart-turned-chair seem like a spot to settle into for the evening.  

Others line their carts with fabric or some other barrier and turn them into planters. Sorry, can’t picture this any way but seriously ugly. I wouldn’t expect a standing ovation from your HOA if you decide to line your sidewalk or driveway with those. 

I have seen some older folks (one might even have given birth to me) using shopping carts as glorified walkers in a Walmart the size of a subdivision. Very effective, actually.

Carts as modern art, maybe. I mean, I’ve seen a sheet of plywood in a museum art exhibit, so why not? As the blood-stained main character in a horror movie, for sure. Theaters would be jammed for the suspense and mayhem of Cart IV. Shopping carts also make excellent, though massively injury-causing, go-karts. But it’s good to support your local ER. 

After you get stitched up, just be sure to return the cart. Or I’ll definitely think less of you.

📝
Tom Allen previously wrote a "Faith and Values" column for the Richmond Times-Dispatch. He is the retired editor of the Virginia Journal of Education and the author of two books, "Grace Happens" and "Roll With It." Contact him at tomed1@hotmail.com.